*Kilchoman Spring 2011 Release 46%ABV
-smelled slightly peaty, earthy with leather
-smokiness like BBQ smoke
-with water - diluted the smell
-sweetness floated to the top
-tasted heavier peat-goes to sour
-trailed bitter oak
*Laphroaig Cairdeas Port Wood Edition 51.3% ABV
-smelled peat with heather, sour floral
-began sweet cough syrup
-tasted strong peat with a strange lull
-floated to the top of mouth with a tinge of sour floral
-with water - can smell port
-tasted heavily peat and smoke
This whisky would be very low on the Aly and Donna
Scale.