We also tasted some other things:
*Michter's Toasted Barrel 45.7% ABV
-smelled BOURBON! oak and vanilla
-tasted sweet oak (almost mint)
-quickly fades to charred oak bitter
-with water smelled oak
-tasted like a cross between oak and wet paper
-finished bitter oak
Water did not make much of a difference. Definitely for mixing.
-smelled very light oak
-tasted cereal grain pepper
-with water smelled like Corn Pops
-tasted sweeter oak
-finished sour oak bitter
Wouldn't say that water ruins this.
-smelled like licorice and cherry candy
-tasted sweet cereal grain
-with water smelled oak and rye
-tasted rye, bitter wood
-finished oak
The taste definitely did not match up to the smell.
-smelled rye and corn
-tasted peppery oak
-with water smelled sweet oak
-tasted sour oak, not bitter
-trailed sweet
Pretty easy drinking whiskey.
-smelled sweet sherry Oloroso
-hints of salty and cinnamon bun
-with water tasted peppery oak
-trailed oak
This one was definitely better without water.
-smelled cinnamon sweet desert
-tasted extremely bitter oak, pepper
-with water got even more bitter
-tasted oak with a faint sweetness at the end
Not good with water. Not very smooth without.
-smelled sweet oak bourbon
-tasted peppery oak
-with water smelled floral
-tasted oaky floral
-trailed sweet oak
Finished unexpectedly for me. I would not go out of my way to find this though.