Here is what we tasted:
*Nikka 12yr 40% ABV A blend of 2 Japanese single malts
-smells sweet caramel, apples
-tastes strong alcohol, slightly woody and trails quickly
-with water - smells a tinge sour
-tastes dry like chardonnay, very sour like paper
-trails quickly
I have tried a few of the Japanese whiskies and this one has something to taste. The others have been shooting whiskies - Kanpai!! It's not what I would call an easy drinking whisky though.
*The Famous Grouse No age statement 40% ABV Blend
-smells garden hose
-tastes rubbery with a peppery taste underneath
-with water - less rubbery
-can't distinguish this from other bland blends
-poured a second taste into a different glass with narrow bottom and wide opening - opened up the smell of flowers and trailed rubber
*Black Grouse 40% ABV Blend
-no rubber like The Famous Grouse
-smells sweet wood with a tinge of burnt wood
-tastes slight peat with a chalky/earthiness
-trails very quickly
-with water - got warm with very little taste
-slight oak but not sweet
This second tasting was a bit different than the first. I was not stuffed full of delicious dinner. Being slightly hungry helps more of the flavors come through.
*Glen Dronach 15yr Oloroso Cask 46% ABV
-smells sweet dessert like cinnamon buns
-tastes a tinge of wine at first then goes almost to a plain flour taste
-with water - smells sawdust/pine
-slightly sweeter and trails quickly
What a difference from the first time I tasted this! I didn't get the peppery/rubbery flavors.